+39 02 48013440

info@studiolegalestella.it

logologologo

  • Ita
  • Eng

  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts

+39 02 48013440

info@studiolegalestella.it

 
logologologo

  • Ita
  • Eng

  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts
logologologo

  • Ita
  • Eng

  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts
logologologo

  • Ita
  • Eng

  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts
logologologo

  • Ita
  • Eng

  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts
  • Home
  • The Firm
    • Professionals
    • Att. at law Prof. Federico Stella
  • Services
    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law
  • Work with us
  • References
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contacts
by StudioStella
Law, Legal services Bankruptcy Criminal Law10 February 20220 comments 0 Likes

Improper bankruptcy for malicious transactions

Bankruptcy crimes, and especially fraudulent bankruptcy, no doubt play a crucial role in corporate criminal law.

This type of crime can be integrated by various conducts, such as the one indicated by article 223, paragraph 2, no. 2 of the Bankruptcy Law. The article configures a hypothesis of improper fraudulent bankruptcy for which directors, general managers, auditors and liquidators of bankruptcy companies that have caused the willful bankruptcy of the company due to malicious transactions can be held accountable.

 

Get bankruptcy advice

Contact us

 

The difference between improper, patrimonial and documentary bankruptcy

There are different types of bankruptcy: improper, patrimonial and documentary. The latter two punish the conducts of distraction and dissipation of corporate assets with danger for credit reasons, regardless of the circumstances that caused the bankruptcy, an event that must occur in any case. On the other hand, improper bankruptcy punishes malicious conducts and operations – not necessarily distractions or dissipations – which must have an etiological connection with the company’s bankruptcy.

In particular and as clarified by the jurisprudence of legitimacy, to configure the crime of improper bankruptcy, the immediate impoverishment of the company does not necessarily have to be detected, but it will be sufficient to detect the creation or aggravation of a situation of economic distress which, predictably, will lead to bankruptcy.

It is for this reason that this type of crime is increasingly common in legal matters relating to the management of companies of any size and industry. In this regard, a recent ruling by the Criminal Cassation, section V, 02.18.2021, no 22765, establishes that “it is a free-form crime, supplemented by active or omissive conduct, constituting failure to comply with the duties respectively imposed on the subjects indicated by the law, in which the bankruptcy is an event of damage. It is believed that the case occurs not only when the failure situation finds its cause in malicious conduct or operations, but also when such conducts and operations have aggravated the failure situation, which is the objective prerequisite for declaring bankruptcy.”

The role of the administrator and the meaning of “malicious operation” 

Concerning the figure of the company director, who has an obligation of loyalty toward the company, it is believed that any violation committed by the director can integrate an intentional operation in the presence of other conditions. As established by the jurisprudence of legitimacy, such intentional operation “consists in performing of any intrinsically dangerous act for the economic and financial health of the company and, therefore, is also an omissive conduct that creates and impoverishment unjustifiable in terms of interest for the company.” (sentence, Criminal Court, section V, 05.15.2014, no 29586).

It is no coincidence that we speak of “operation”, a much broader term than “action” (i.e., merely active conduct) and also including omissive conduct. In this regard, in the case law it is precisely stated that malicious operations may also consist of the systematic failure to pay social security contributions or taxes.

 

Get bankruptcy advice

Contact us

 

“Willful misconduct” in improper bankruptcy

The regulatory use of the word “willful” in the context of the subjective element of the crime must be understood as follows: bankruptcy must be foreseen and wanted by an agent as a consequence of their action or omission. Hence, it only refers to cases in which the company’s bankruptcy was the agent’s goal. In the hypothesis of malicious transactions, however, bankruptcy is only the effect of the agent’s voluntary conduct but not intentionally aimed at generating bankruptcy.

Therefore, the first instance is punished only in direct event fraud, while in the second case generic fraud will suffice.

With regard to the case for malicious transactions, the Supreme Court (with the sentence cited, Criminal Court, Section V, 02.18.2021, no. 22765) found that “reference was made to a hypothesis of unintentional bankruptcy, to underline that the connection with the event is purely coincidental, as the ‘for the effect of’ formula suggests, where the fraud only refers to the operations that cause the failure.” It is hence “sufficient for the prosecution to prove” the awareness and intention of the administrator of the complex action affecting patrimonial damage in its natural elements and contrast with his/her duties, in the face of the interests of the company, and their insertion in the wake of the aforementioned need for the abstract predictability of the event of instability as an effect of the illegal action. “

Considering what is established by the jurisprudence of legitimacy and in light of the increasingly significant impact of improper fraudulent bankruptcy in corporate affairs, we suggest requesting the support of legal professionals experienced in Criminal Bankruptcy Law, both in the judicial and extrajudicial phases. Stella Law Firm can help you.

 

Contact us now

    Share
    The Legislative Decree n. 231/2001 turns twenty: this is why it is so importantPrev
    Corporate Governance: the three models available to joint-stock companiesNext

    Latest Posts

    by StudioStella

    Copyright: what it is, how long it lasts, what it protects

    We often hear about copyright, but the underlying concept of copyright may not always be clear: what exactly is it about? Does it have a specific duration?...

    Copyright: what it is, how long it lasts, what it protects

    Copyright Criminal Law, Law6 October 2020
    Share
    by StudioStella

    Guarantees and criminal liability of the person in charge of workplace safety

    The legislation on the prevention of accidents in the workplace aims to establish a network of guarantors who can deal in a timely and effective manner with...

    Guarantees and criminal liability of the person in charge of workplace safety

    Labour Criminal Law, Law19 March 2021
    Share
    by StudioStella

    What is Copyright Criminal Law and why it is important

    In our blog, we have previously dealt with copyright, exploring its definition and duration and its scope of protection. The term “Copyright” identifies...

    What is Copyright Criminal Law and why it is important

    Copyright Criminal Law, Law17 April 2021
    Share
    logo Studio Legale Stella

    Stella Law Associates support multinational companies and managers of medium and large enterprises in solving problems both of a criminal and, when needed, civil nature, either judicial or preventive and extrajudicial.

    Offices

    Via Alberto da Giussano 15
    20145 Milano MI – Italy

    info@studiolegalestella.it

    +39 02 48013440
    +39 02 4819040
    +39 02 4819066
    Icona LinkedIn

    Services

    • Corporate Criminal Law
    • Environmental Criminal Law
    • Labour Criminal Law
    • Bankruptcy Criminal Law
    • Tax Criminal Law
    • Copyright Criminal Law
    • Company Law
    • Commercial Law

    Latest from the Blog

    • When can you file a report, a complaint or a statement?
      When can you file a report, a complaint or a statement?
    • When should you seek legal advice from a criminal lawyer?
      When should you seek legal advice from a criminal lawyer?
    • Notice of investigation: why you should immediately contact a criminal lawyer
      Notice of investigation: why you should immediately contact a criminal lawyer

    © 2020 Stella Law Associates | VAT no. 05535570963 | SEO by Naxa

    Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy